The Ultimate Guide to Writing Expired Listing Letter That Get Responses

For those unfamiliar, expired listing letters are correspondences directed to property owners whose listings have lapsed without resulting in a sale. The key difficulty lies not in sending one expired listing letter but in crafting it in a way that prompts a reply.

Expired Listing Letter

Reflect on the situation of a homeowner who has spent a significant amount of time with their property on the market, only to confront the reality of their listing expiring without a sale. This outcome likely results in a combination of frustration and disappointment stemming from their unfulfilled expectations. This strategy goes beyond simply announcing your services. It’s about developing a message that empathetically expresses, “I understand the challenges you’re facing, and I’m here to provide help.”

This guide will help you create an expired listing letter that does more than just land in a mailbox – it opens doors. We’ll discuss achieving the right tone, hitting key points, and importantly, making your letter stand out from generic real estate mail.

What is an Expired Listing Letter?

Why do listings expire? There can be several reasons, ranging from overpricing to ineffective marketing, or external factors like market or economic shifts. However, expired listings are a hidden treasure for you, the real estate agents. They represent homeowners ready to sell but who haven’t succeeded yet. They might feel discouraged or uncertain about their next steps, and that’s where you come in to offer guidance and solutions.

Key Components of a Successful Expired Listing Letter

Personal Touch with Their Name

Start off on the right foot by using the homeowner’s name, not a bland “Dear Homeowner.” It sets a welcoming tone, like a smile in your introduction.

Engaging Introduction

Begin with an empathetic note. Try something like, “Noticed your beautiful home is seeking a buyer again. Time to change that, right?”

Highlighting Your Edge (UVP)

This is where you shine. Explain why you’re the go-to realtor for them. Perhaps you’re renowned for swift sales in their area, or your marketing strategies are top-notch.

Success Tales (Evidence)

Showcase your achievements with a brief but powerful client success story or testimonial. It’s your way of reassuring them that they’re in capable hands.

Clear Call to Action (CTA)

Conclude by suggesting an easy next step, such as “Fancy a quick call to discuss your property?” and include your contact details for straightforward communication.

Finishing with Flair

Sign off in a manner that reflects your personality. Opt for a “Best wishes” or “Yours truly,” then your name and contact info – it’s the perfect final touch to your letter.

Writing Tips for Maximum Impact

This guide will guide you through a structured conversation framework designed to effectively re-engage these homeowners. By incorporating empathy, strategic questioning, and tailored solutions, you can transform a simple call into an opportunity to rebuild confidence and secure a new listing.

Follow these steps to enhance your approach and improve your outcomes in these crucial interactions.

1. Pattern Interrupt

Start the conversation in a way that breaks the usual sales call pattern. This can be as simple as acknowledging that the homeowner might be busy and giving them the option to end the call. This not only shows respect for their time but also positions you as considerate, increasing their willingness to continue the conversation.

2. Self-Identification and Permission

Quickly identify yourself as a real estate agent and ask permission to continue. This establishes transparency and builds trust from the outset. For example, you might say, “Hi, this is [Your Name], and I’m a real estate agent. I know you’re busy, so if you’re not interested, feel free to let me know.”

3. Spark Curiosity

Once you have permission, shift the conversation to evoke curiosity. Ask a question that makes them think about their situation from a new angle, such as, “I noticed your home didn’t sell. Do you think there was a specific reason it wasn’t as successful on the market?”

4. Discover Pain Points

Encourage the homeowner to express their thoughts on why the property didn’t sell. This not only gives you insight into their frustrations but also helps you understand how to offer value. For instance, “When you were receiving updates, did your agent discuss why your home might not be selling?”

5. Validate Their Experience

Show empathy and understanding for their situation. Validate their feelings about the process, which can be very frustrating. This builds a deeper emotional connection, making them more receptive to your solutions.

6. Offer Solutions

Based on the pain points they’ve shared, propose a specific, tailored strategy that addresses their concerns. For example, “Given what you’ve shared, I believe a more proactive marketing approach and consistent communication could really make a difference. Would you be open to hearing more about how we can address these issues?”

7. Soft Commitment

Transition into setting up a meeting with a soft commitment that respects their autonomy. This could look like, “Would you be opposed to me stopping by to discuss this in person? We can look at what didn’t work before and explore options that might get us a different result.”

8. Close with Confidence

Finish the conversation by affirming that the decision is in their hands, which reassures them that they are not being pressured. You might say, “If after our discussion, you feel that the approach I suggest might work for you, we can talk about the next steps. If not, no hard feelings at all.”

Examples and Templates

Alright, let’s make all that advice a bit more tangible with a solid example of what an effective expired listing letter looks like.

Think of it as an expired listings letter template, but remember, the magic is in tweaking it to fit each unique situation.

Here’s a great expired listing letter for you:

Hey [Homeowner’s Name],

Just saw that your awesome place at [Property Address] is up for grabs again. It’s not just any house – it’s got the potential to be someone’s dream home, and it should really shine in the spotlight.

I’ve got a knack for giving listings that didn’t sell initially a new lease on life. What sets me apart is [your unique selling point here]. Take last month, for example – I worked with someone in your shoes and [a quick success story].

I’d be super excited to chat about how we can get your property the attention it deserves. Feel free to drop me a line at [Your Contact Info], and let’s talk about a fresh game plan for your home.

Can’t wait to potentially team up with you.

Best, [Your Name and Title]

So, why does this work?

Gets Personal Right Off the Bat – It kicks off by addressing the homeowner directly. That instantly makes it feel more one-on-one.

Empathy Up Front – By recognizing the property’s beauty and potential, it starts on a really positive and understanding note.

Your Unique Touch – It clearly spells out what makes your approach special. Stand out from the crowd!

Success Story – A quick example of your past wins adds some serious credibility and trust.

Easy Next Step – Wrapping up with an invite to talk more makes it super easy for them to reach out.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

You now have the idea of a solid expired listing letter template. Next, let’s look at the common mistakes in writing expired listing letters and how you can avoid them. 

1. Going Generic

Mistake Example:

Sending expired listings letters that feels like it could be addressed to anyone is a common error. It lacks personalization and can lead to lower response rates.

Improved Example:

Hello, Mr. Johnson! Your exquisite three-bedroom home on Elm Street has caught my eye, and I see that it recently expired from the market. I’m eager to meet with you and discuss a tailored strategy that truly matches your individual goals.

Why It’s Effective:

Personalization – In the great expired listings letter content example, we address the seller by name and acknowledge specific details about their property, showcasing genuine interest and effort.

Invitation to Collaborate – It invites the seller to engage in a genuine conversation rather than receiving a standard sales pitch.

Empathy – The improved example expresses empathy by recognizing the significance of the seller’s decision, creating a more welcoming and open dialogue.

2. Pushy Language

Mistake Example:

Using expired listings typical sound that appears forceful or demanding can be counterproductive, as it may make potential clients uncomfortable.

Improved Example:

I understand that deciding to sell your home is a substantial decision. But let me know if you think you’re prepared to take the next step. 

Why It’s Effective:

– Empathy and Understanding: The improved example begins with empathy, acknowledging the weight of the seller’s decision. It positions you as a supportive resource rather than a pushy salesperson.

– Open Invitation: It leaves the door wide open for the seller to reach out when they’re comfortable and ready, fostering a more relaxed and collaborative atmosphere.

3. Lack of Clarity

Mistake Example:

Send expired listings letters with vague instructions can leave sellers wondering about the next steps.

Improved Example:

Let’s take the next step together. You can decide whether you’d like to connect via phone at [your phone number] or opt for a quick reply to this email, allowing us to schedule a consultation that aligns with your timetable.

Why It’s Effective:

Clear Call to Action

Such improved expired listing letter samples provide a straightforward and actionable call to action, making it easy for the seller to understand what the next move should be.

Assurance of Convenience

It assures the seller that the process will be convenient and flexible, reducing any potential anxiety about taking the next step.

Tracking and Improving Your Response Rate

It’s essential for your success, and here’s why:

Data-Driven Decisions

Tracking responses provides insights. For instance, if you notice that mentioning recent successful sales in the expired listing leads to better responses, you can prioritize this in future letters.

Fine-Tuning Your Approach

Tracking helps you adapt to specific market segments. For example, you might find that condos respond better to your letters than single-family homes in a diverse neighborhood.

Measuring ROI

By tracking responses and calculating ROI, you can assess the effectiveness of your marketing budget.

Methods for Testing and Improving Letter Effectiveness

Now, let’s explore actionable methods to test and enhance the effectiveness of your expired listing letters:

A/B Testing – Experiment with different letter versions. For instance, test whether including a success story boosts response rates.

Follow-Up Timing – Timing matters. Adjust follow-up intervals based on response data to maximize receptivity.

Content Tweaks – Continuously refine your letter content. For example, adding a personal success story can make your letters more persuasive.

Multichannel Approach – Use multiple communication channels. If a seller engages on social media but doesn’t respond to a letter, adapt your approach accordingly.

Feedback Solicitation – Seek feedback from responsive sellers to fine-tune your content. Highlight elements that resonate with your audience.

Professional Review – Get input from colleagues or mentors to identify areas for improvement. External perspectives can be invaluable.

CRM Software – Utilize CRM software for efficient follow-ups and record keeping, ensuring no opportunity is overlooked.

Crafting Eye-Catching Envelopes

In writing expired listing letters, the envelope plays a crucial role in grabbing the homeowner’s attention before they even open your letter.

Here are some tips for crafting eye-catching envelopes for your expired listing letters:

  1. Colorful and Unique Designs – Consider using colorful envelopes with unique designs that stand out in a stack of mail. Vibrant colors and interesting patterns can make your envelope more visually appealing.
  2. Handwritten Fonts – Use handwritten fonts for the recipient’s name and address. Handwritten elements add a personal touch and make the envelope look less like mass-produced marketing material.
  3. Teaser Messages – Include a teaser message on the front of the envelope that arouses curiosity. For example, you could write, “Unlock the Secret to Selling Your Home,” or “Your Home Deserves a Second Chance.”
  4. Quality Printing – Ensure that the printing quality of your envelope is top-notch. Clear and sharp images and text create a professional and polished appearance.
  5. Custom Stamps or Seals – Consider using custom stamps or seals with your logo or branding to make the envelope even more unique and memorable.
  6. Handwritten Notes – If possible, include a handwritten note on the envelope itself, even if it’s just a short “Hello!” or a smiley face. Handwritten touches can make a significant difference in personalizing your message.
  7. Size Variation – Experiment with different envelope sizes to make your letter stand out further. A non-standard envelope size can be intriguing and break the monotony of regular mail.

Wrapping Up

Your journey to writing effective expired listing letters begins with understanding the importance of tracking responses and continuously improving your approach. Remember, personalization, timing, and a multichannel strategy can make a significant difference. Seek feedback, adapt, and keep learning. Now, it’s your turn to put these insights into practice in your next expired listing letter campaign. Happy writing, and may your responses soar!

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get updates and learn from the best

More To Explore


How to Stage a House for Sale Inexpensively

Home staging is more than just cleaning up and arranging furniture. It’s about creating an environment that allows potential buyers to envision themselves living in

Do you want
more leads?

Looking for more leads? I’m Brent Gray, and I specialize in boosting businesses through lead generation. Is your business ready for growth?

About Brent Gray

Brent Gray is the founder of Be Greight. Fueled by entrepreneurial spirit and a passion for marketing, he excels in helping businesses achieve their full potential. Known for his strategic insights and data-driven approach, Brent has become a key player in the marketing industry. His expertise in executing impactful marketing campaigns and utilizing innovative tools positions him as a trusted resource for businesses aiming to boost leads and conversions.


Do You Want To Boost Your Business?

drop us a line and keep in touch


Learn how we helped 100 top brands gain success.

Let's have a chat